I want to talk about this book, The Inner Game of Tennis by W. Timothy Gallwey, but somehow without sounding preachy. At its core it’s a book about sports psychology, with an admixture of self help, and while I like sports psychology, anything with a whiff of self help makes me uneasy. As a genre, self help preys on people’s nagging feeling that there’s some secret out there that they don’t yet know, but can quickly learn, which will solve all of their problems with effective habits, weight loss, making money, or influencing people. And there’s no secret, not really.

So, I want to talk about this book without pretending like it has some answer to life’s problems. But the fact is, it has the answer to one question that has been nagging me for a long time. It has to do with breaks.

I like learning new hobbies and skills, especially ones that are technically challenging: programming, fixing typewriters or motorcycles, observational sketching, skateboarding, etc. etc. And I’m always in the same pattern with these hobbies.

  1. Learn lots.
  2. Practice.
  3. Plateau and feel stuck.
  4. Get drawn into another hobby or skill.
  5. Return after a break to find that I’ve somehow gotten past my plateau, that I can do the thing better than before.

And that last bullet point drives me nuts because it’s like I’m unwittingly improving at something when I’m not doing it at all.

For a time I assumed it was because my brain/nervous system needed a break to cement good habits, or something. That muscle memory worked better with breaks. But that just didn’t feel like the right answer. And if my mind was just a bit clearer on returning, that doesn’t seem to explain the way I get measurably better after a break. Not just returning to peak form, but actual improvement.

And then I read The Inner Game of Tennis, which I had been recommended once or twice on the internet, and sure enough it breaks the whole thing wide open. This phenomenon of breaks causing improvement suddenly felt understandable.

One of Gallwey’s points is that we are “in the zone” when we’re both at ease and alert, with our full attention on the activity we’re doing. The zone is fragile to any lapses in concentration, including ones that are well-meaning. What I mean is that if you concentrate on form, you’re not in the zone. If you concentrate on the outcome of the match, you’re not in the zone. If you’re trying to apply what you’ve learned, you’re at practice, not in the zone.

Moreover, any attention spent on worrying about your self-image or negative consequences is attention that is taken away from the activity itself. In tennis, you shift from “Can I return this serve?” to “What if I can’t return this serve?”

What’s always bothered me is my sense that after some time spent learning, I feel like I should have improved by now. If I haven’t learned, then I’ve been messing up. So I look for evidence of improvement, I lose focus, and I falter.

Or, another failure mode: I’ve read books, watched videos, and picked up lots of little tips for each part of my technique. All this advice rattles around in my head, encouraging my ego to use some of it so it doesn’t go to waste. I forget my real goal, I lose focus, and I falter.

I take a break for a few weeks or months, get invested in something else, and forget everything I know about hobby X for a bit. And then my interest gets sparked again and I pick it up, only to find my mind clear, my worries gone, the little technical tips silent. I switch from asking myself, “Have I gotten better?” to “Remember what you like so much about this?”

It’s no wonder I do the thing better than before!

The improvement is not just a result of rest or settling in of the nervous system. My mind is clearer and unconcerned, but focused, and that leads to better all-around performance. But interestingly, a short period after I return to my hobby, things get cluttered again.

So… how do you harness this clear-mindedness so you can do well without taking a long break? That’s the real subject of Gallwey’s book. So that’s my recommendation – to all those who are stuck, cursed with knowing the right idea but not being able to execute it (“Head down!”), or are simply not having fun, take a read through this book and see if it doesn’t help.

Some other recommended reading:

  • Zen in the Art of Archery. Classic text on zen performance (from which Gallwey takes a some influence). Update: safe to skip this one, see this follow-up
  • Ratings Fear and Loathing. Great blogpost about chess ratings in particular. It’s hepled me a lot with my rating worries when I play Go. The rest of this blog is great, too, for brain sport psychology in general. For a look at how chess and tennis in particular are linked, check out this series of posts
  • Harvey Penick’s Little Red Book. No one knows suffering like golfers. The Golf Channel is the only channel I’ve seen where in between commercials, they sometimes give a quick golf lesson. I read Harvey Penick’s book when I was a teen golfer and it helped me a lot with understanding how to apply advice, how to focus (“Take dead aim!”), and, incidentally, with my short game.

And some other things that Gallwey’s book helped me understand:

  • Verbal advice is rarely helpful.
  • A bad habit is simply a crude solution to a real problem. If you find a better solution, bad habits disappear quite easily. (In school, I found it easy to change how I wrote certain letters if I found a form I liked better. All I did every day was write, so if habits were hard to break, this should’ve been impossible.)
  • I was asked to design the cocktail napkin for my friend’s wedding – a sketch of her two bunny rabbits. I’m emphatically not a professional artist, but I accepted. I did dozens of drafts without finding one that I liked, and the pressure seemed like it was getting to me. And one day I went to a cafe with my wife, Bre, and drew a pair of sketches of the buns, directly and in pen, in a realistic style unlike my previous line drawings. I frankly don’t remember what was going through my head when I was doing them, probably nothing much. And that was the design that ended up on the napkin.

And now, to wrap things up, a zen story.

When one goes to Obaku temple in Kyoto he sees carved over the gate the words “The First Principle.”

The letters are unusually large, and those who appreciate calligraphy always admire them as being a masterpiece. They were drawn by Kosen two hundred years ago.

When the master drew them he did so on paper, from which workmen made the larger carving in wood. As Kosen sketched the letters a bold pupil was with him who had made several gallons of ink for the calligraphy and who never failed to criticize his master’s work.

“That is not good,” he told Kosen after the first effort.

“How is that one?”

“Poor. Worse than before,” pronounced the pupil.

Kosen patiently wrote one sheet after another until eighty-four First Principles had been accumulated, still without the approval of the pupil.

Then, when the young man stepped outside for a few moments, Kosen thought: “Now is my chance to escape his keen eye,” and he wrote hurriedly, with a mind free from distraction. “The First Principle.”

“A masterpiece,” pronounced the pupil.

Updated: